|

The Red State Strategy Meets the Midterms

School-choice advocates want to rebuild bipartisan support. They’re hoping people have short memories.

On November 18, the American Enterprise Institute, a free-market think tank, held a panel called “What Now for School Choice in the States?” AEI’s Frederick M. Hess moderated a discussion with Daniel Buck of AEI, Starlee Coleman of the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, Robert Enlow of EdChoice, and Matthew Ladner of the Heritage Foundation. They spent much of the hour talking about how to defend vouchers, education savings accounts, and charter schools after Democrats gained ground in state elections. 

To put it mildly, these folks are freaking out.

The Red State Strategy Worked. Now They’re Trapped By It.

As Buck explained it, the red state strategy was simple. School-choice advocates concentrated on states where Republicans controlled the governorship and both legislative chambers. They used those majorities to push through the broadest voucher and education savings account programs they could, without needing to engage Democrats.

They also leaned into the culture wars. Buck acknowledged that attacking public schools helped make private school choice a conservative cause and helped drive several years of rapid expansion. It also alienated the Democrats the movement now needs to work with. And, it appears to have split conservatives by labeling their beloved rural public schools as the enemy.

Now Buck wants move away from the culture wars ane refocus on the case for school choice as a way to help students with disabilities and students from low-income families. He said they have lots of supportive research and rhetoric that they need to dust off and bring back out. Enlow stressed the need to rebuild relationships across party lines. And when asked directly, the panelists agreed that they needed to convince folks that strong rural public schools and school choice could coexist. Buck’s assessment of the political challenge was refreshingly candid. “I’m hoping people’s political memory is short.”

Good luck putting that genie back in the bottle! People tend to remember when you make their children’s school, and their favorite teachers, the villain in your campaign.

And how, exactly, will they rebuild relationships with people they describe as “not overly encumbered by the truth”? That was Ladner’s characterization of choice opponents. Coleman called Gina Hinojosa “immune to factual information on charter schools,” without identifying a specific claim listeners could check.

The Arguments The Choice Advocates Are Worried About

Public school advocates should pay attention to the messaging the panelists felt was most effective against expanding choice.

  1. If public money pays for it, show us where it goes and whether students are learning. This was the strongest argument of the afternoon, and it came from the moderator. Hess imagined a lawmaker asking for good records of how families spend taxpayer dollars and assessments that show whether children are learning. He called it “a very compelling narrative.” Coleman said a “blank check with no strings attached” was hard to defend. Enlow challenged the idea that district testing produces meaningful accountability, while Ladner accepted the need for financial safeguards and was open to some testing. Ladner argued that common state standards and tests would limit the kinds of education schools could offer. That leaves a basic question for Florida. What evidence will families and taxpayers have to judge how well students are learning across the options they fund?
  2. Who gets the subsidy, and what does it cost the public schools? Buck singled out the argument that vouchers benefit affluent families and take money away from public schools as one reason bipartisan support would be harder to rebuild. Enlow compared the size of the Texas choice program with total statewide education spending, suggesting the impact was negligible to Texas public schools. Tell that to a school board trying to keep a neighborhood school open.There’s another question lawmakers should answer. Before citing weak public-school performance as a reason to expand vouchers, what was done to ensure those public schools had the resources they needed to succeed? Current research demonstrates that money does matter: increases in school funding can improve student outcomes, especially for children from low-income families, and that funding cuts can worsen outcomes. If public-school test scores can be used to make the case for expanding vouchers, what comparable evidence of student learning will lawmakers require from the voucher programs they continue to fund?
  3. What are taxpayers actually paying for and who is guarding against waste, fraud and abuse? Buck said critics can easily get voters’ attention by talking about flat-screen TVs and Disney trips, examples he called unfair portrayals of the programs. His answer was to make participation easier so more families would have a stake in defending it. That is simply a political strategy for voucher advocates. Taxpayers will still have legitimate questions of their own. What did our public money actually buy, who approved it, and what happened when a purchase violated the rules? 
  4. Communities still choose their public schools. The panelists noted rural Republicans did not take kindly to the culture wars and the threats to their public schools. They felt strong rural public schools belonged in the “choice” conversation and could coexist with choice schools. I’d like to hear what that means when a community faces a school closure. What are choice advocates willing to ask lawmakers to do to keep a high-quality public school available for the families who chose it?

A Threat To Charter Independence

Coleman warned that an anticipated Supreme Court ruling barring states from excluding religious charter schools could force legislatures to revisit their charter laws. She suggested that some states might respond by putting charters under greater district control, potentially costing them the independent boards and operating flexibility that charter advocates value. That was her most pointed warning about a threat to charter autonomy, and it concerned litigation coming from within the broader school-choice movement.

What Florida’s Public-School Advocates Should Be Asking About

I’m tired of hearing our neighborhood public schools described as the “default choice.” My family chose our local public schools. Both of our children graduated from Coral Shores High School and went on to succeed at excellent universities. Florida lawmakers should give our choice the same amount of respect they give to the choices of families using a voucher.

So let’s take these arguments to Tallahassee and turn them into demands lawmakers can act on.

  • Show us where the money goes. Put private-school vouchers and education savings accounts in a separate appropriation outside the Florida Education Finance Program (FEFP). Make funding streams transparent and accountable. Report voucher spending and the flow of public dollars to charter schools clearly enough for taxpayers to easily follow.
  • Tell us who benefits. Publish how many new voucher recipients were already in private school or home education, how many came from public schools, and who receives the subsidies by income. Report on the number of students leaving vouchers for public schools. If lawmakers are making the case for expansion on behalf of low-income families and students with disabilities, show us who the expansion actually serves.
  • Show us what we’re paying for and whether students are learning. Publish what public funds buy, how improper payments are handled, and what independent evaluations find about student progress. Publish the 2024–25 Learning Systems Institute evaluation of student performance in the Florida Tax Credit (FTC) and Family Empowerment Scholarship (FES) scholarship programs. If it’s still pending, tell the public when to expect it. Give families that information in time to use it and lawmakers in time to act on it.
  • Show us what “doubling down” would do to our public schools. Publish a district-by-district enrollment forecast that accounts for declining birth rates, out-migration, shifts to charter schools, private schools and home education, and any documented effects of immigration enforcement. Then show how the proposed expansion would change enrollment and funding relative to that forecast. Explain how Florida will protect access to a high-quality community public school when enrollment falls faster than the cost of keeping that school open.

If your legislators support doubling down on school choice, ask them one question. What will you do to protect and improve the public schools our families have already chosen?

Similar Posts