| |

Is there a respectful synonym for “punish?”

BySuzette

Accountabaloney Graphic2_SMALLIt has come to our attention that some accountabaloney terms may need to be better defined.  Let’s take a look at the word “punish” and discuss whether that word is a “respectful” word that accurately describes the consequences of high stakes testing in Florida.

On Oct 1, 2015, the  Florida Learning Committee (FLC) convened to discuss everything from accountability to class size. Last winter, in response to outcries regarding overtesting in our public schools, Governor Scott ordered the formation of the FLC, which was to be composed of educators, policy makers and parent representatives from across the state (click here for more info).   During the October 1st brainstorming session, a parent representative, Julia (Megan) Hendricks from Pasco County raised a very important issue, the issue of the high stakes connected to the state assessments.  You can watch entire meeting here (the interaction begins at 1:13:58).

“I would like to piggyback on what several  people have said about the use of assessments, because we are in actuality using it, the FSA, for much more than informing instruction, I mean there are some pretty high stakes attached. I think we’re all pretty aware of what those are as far as evaluating teachers, schools, retention…. so I’d like to even go further and be even a little bit more bold and say that we should reconsider using standardized test to evaluate and punish students, teachers, and schools.”

Commissioner Pam Stewart, immediately, interrupted the brainstorming session (which, I believe, is against “brainstorming rules”) to interject “…we at the State are not punishing…”

When Ms. Hendricks repeated her concern, Brian Dassler responded (in what seems quite condescending):

Response from Brian Dassler, Deputy Chancellor for Educator Quality at the Department:

“I’m going to say that punishing is probably not a respectful use of the word, Megan, because I don’t think it would be appropriate to assign intent there. If you would like to amend that word to something else that would capture what you are trying to say, but in a way that would be  respectful…”

Ms. Hendricks, struggling to find a “respectful” synonym for “punish”, replies that she chose the word “punish” because “that’s the way it is perceived by parents“.

Is “punish” used appropriately in discussion of Florida’s high stakes accountability system? Let’s look at its Google definition:

FullSizeRender

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

According to Google, punish means “to treat (someone) in an unfairly harsh way” as in “raising the achievement levels after a test was given would punish low income, children of color.”

As an aside, while investigating for this blog, we also learned that “rigorous” is a synonym for “punishing”, and, well, rigorous is one of Pam Stewart’s favorite, most often used words… perhaps we’ll save the discussion of rigor for a future blog post.

Why would parents feel the state uses FSA scores in a punitive way? What are the ways that Florida’s system appears to punish or penalize teachers, students or schools?

Here are a few examples:

If this is not punishing, or at least the threat of punishment, then we respectfully ask the DOE to please explain what they would consider is punishing?  The DOE may consider these unintended consequences, but at the end of the day, the enormity of the imposed consequences can no longer be viewed as “unintended.”

The high stakes attached to our Florida assessments ARE a huge problem and they ARE punishing students, teachers and schools, whether the DOE finds the terminology respectful or not.  If the Department of Education wants to retain any measure of respect, open discussions regarding the punitive nature of these high stakes tests are vital.  Ms. Stewart’s nitpicking of the use of the word “punish” was not respectful to Ms. Hendricks, especially since “punish” is a word that is widely used and understood throughout the state and nation to accurately represent what is happening in our schools.

Commissioner Stewart appears to be trying to hide the issue of high stakes under the rug, where nobody can see it.  However, for most parents, the problems associated with punitive high stakes are front and center. By continually choosing to ignore legitimate concerns from parents and educators across the state, it is Commissioner Stewart and the FLDOE who are acting disrespectfully.

If the DOE doesn’t want to be accused of “punishing” then it should become less punitive. If they want to regain respect, they should begin by respecting the real concerns of their stakeholders.

Across Florida, parents and educators are discussing the need to remove the high stakes from the state’s standardized testing. We respectfully request the DOE join us in that conversation.

Many thanks to Ms. Hendricks for boldly representing parents and choosing a word that accurately reflects our concerns regarding the use of FSA scores.

 

 

Similar Posts

71 Comments

  20. Stick to 96%+ RTP pokies to stretch your bankroll,
    and read the bonus terms before you claim anything. On our list,
    SpinJo (under 3h), Neon54 (1–3h) and MyEmpire (same-day) are among the quickest.
    Your first withdrawal takes longer (12-48 hours) because of ID checks.

    References: forum.libernesia.org

  21. Bei deiner Einzahlung im Casino mit Sofort kannst du auch von umfangreichen Bonusangeboten wie
    Freispielen, einem Willkommensbonus, einem Reload Bonus
    und oftmals auch einem Cashback Bonus profitieren. Nutze gleich unseren Sofortüberweisung Online Casino Vergleich und starte direkt mit aufregenden Bonusangeboten durch.

    Trotz einiger Einschränkungen wie der Nichtverfügbarkeit für Auszahlungen und
    möglichen Transaktionslimits überwiegen die Vorteile der Sofort Casinos.

  22. Needless to say, the team here at Mr. Gamble has assured that each casino on our above list meets
    all these safety expectations. One way to check the legal
    status of an instant wire transfer casino is by its licensing.

    Here are a few features of a casino you need to consider when choosing one to play at.
    At a casino instant banking setup, balances update once the transfer
    clears. Classic casino games like blackjack and roulette are ready to welcome you
    to the tables.

  28. You can attach multiple payment methods to the Sticpay e-wallet, such as payment cards and cryptocurrencies. Users need to pay very small fees when making transactions with Skrill. Check the table below for more information on the leading online gaming providers in the country. Our experts have done research and they’ve made an assessment of the highest-ranked gambling platforms in the country that offer e-wallet https://www.mashinky.cz/forum/topic/payid-casinos-2026-fastest-withdrawals-tested-0-2h-payouts/. Finish your comparison with a skycrown casino review to see how the site stacks up for Australian players. For platform-specific details, read a richard casino review, a ripper casino review, and a rocket casino review before signing up.

  30. Dieser Artikel liefert konkrete Beispiele, Limits, Gebühren, Alternativen und Sicherheitstipps für Spieler in Deutschland. Dadurch können Spieler flexibel am Desktop, Smartphone oder Tablet einzahlen und spielen. Bei Casiqo finden Sie geeignete Betreiber die hohe Limits für https://inviewsalespro.com/forum/d/314-beste-klarna-casinos-legalitat-zahlungen-vergleichüberweisung bieten. Einzahlungen sind meist kostenlos, denn die Plattformen möchten Spielern den Einstieg so einfach wie möglich machen.

  40. Hervorzuheben ist etwa der Willkommensbonus mit bis zu 100 € und bis zu 100 Freispielen. Dein Vorteil ist, dass du aus mehreren der bekanntesten Slots wählen kannst. Ebenso wie bei bwin ist die Auswahl der Zahlungsmethoden facettenreich. https://survivalgeargurus.com/discussion/flarum/public/d/368-trustly-auszahlung-erfahrungen-dauer-kosten-probleme ist ein Direktbuchungssystem aus Schweden, das mittlerweile nicht nur in Europa verfügbar ist. Entdecken Sie bet365 mit 50 Freispielen Angebot muss binnen 30 Tagen nach Registrierung von bet365-Konto beansprucht werden.

  42. Among the best Neosurf casinos Australia players can consider, Rolling Slots places considerable emphasis on cashback, reloads, loyalty rewards and recurring promotional events. Before making a deposit, check the current payment options and review the available methods for receiving winnings, as payout choices may differ from the deposit methods supported. Slots Gallery supports https://www.devopsschool.com/forum/d/6579-australian-online-casinos-neosurf-fees-safety-guide as a prepaid funding option when listed in the casino cashier. Slots Gallery takes third place for players who put game selection high on their list.

  50. Plus, all games are available on mobile, and the experience is good enough that JustCasino also made my list of the best mobile casinos in Australia. JustCasino is another site that does many things well and accepts Neosurf for deposits, so it has easily earned a place on this list. Wincrown takes the #2 spot because it combines a great bonus offering with an exceptional game library and fast withdrawals. Here’s the list of the casinos that delivered the best overall experience for Australian players. Below, you’ll find my picks for the best https://forum.rukoeu.com/d/183-neosurf-casino-neosurf-casino-reviews-bonuses-2026 casinos in Australia, along with everything you should know about using prepaid vouchers for casino deposits.

  51. Using PayID as your payment method at online casinos in Australia not only offers quick and secure transactions but also opens the door to a variety of exciting bonuses. When it comes to withdrawals in online https://clubdelemprendedoruned.com/comunidad/topic/the-business-of-payid-facebook-pokies/, the usual limits range from AU$ 50 to AU$ 10,000 per transaction. The Pay ID transfer itself is close to instant after approval — the main variable is how long the payid withdrawal casino spends checking KYC, wagering completion, and risk flags before it initiates the payment. At payid online casinos, you use the casino’s Pay ID address for deposits and your own Pay ID for withdrawals, with transfers routed securely through your bank’s own app environment. If a brand routinely leaves Pay ID withdrawals in pending status for more than two business days without explanation, it should not be treated as a genuine instant payid withdrawal casino regardless of what its marketing claims about casinos with PayID. The first window is casino approval time — how long the operator spends running its own KYC, wagering, and fraud checks before it releases the funds.

  55. Wer im Online Casino Sofortüberweisung nutzt, um Geld auf das Spielerkonto einzuzahlen, verwendet eine der unkompliziertesten Zahlungsmethoden überhaupt. Bereits seit 2005 nutzen deutsche Spieler im Online https://nasarallysport.com/forum/public/d/11-spielautomaten-sofortuberweisung-sicher-einzahlen Sofortüberweisung für komfortable, schnelle Einzahlungen. Eines der E-Wallet Anbieter Neteller und Skrill ist oftmals prädestiniert für Transaktionen. Es bedarf nur einen Eintrag einer PIN und TAN Nummer auf dem Zahlungsformular, welches ihr auf der Sofortüberweisung Webseite findet, um die Transaktionen durchführen zu können. Wer in den SOFORT Casinos mobil Geld einzahlen möchte, muss nur den Kassenbereich öffnen und die Transaktion durchführen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *