| |

Better Outcomes. Fewer Tests. Not Imaginary.

BySuzette

Facebook Icon

Across Florida, parents are concerned about the over emphasis of high stakes testing in our public schools. We are being told that standardized testing “is not going anywhere” and is necessary to ensure accountability. Is that true? Can schools be held accountable for providing quality education without over-reliance on standardized tests?

What if you learned there were accountability systems, well documented in America today, that showed consistently better results than test based accountability systems?  Higher graduation rates, fewer dropout, better teacher retention, high college acceptance/attendance. Better Outcomes. Fewer Tests. Sounds good, right?

One such system is demonstrating such successes  and it is called “Performance Based Assessments”. Jay Mathews gives an excellent introduction, “Intriguing alternative to rating schools by tests”, written in 2010,  here. Would Florida be willing to investigate such a system?

Apparently not.  Today I called the Florida Department of Education to ask who I could talk to about Performance Based Assessments. It was like I was speaking a foreign language.  They had “performance base pay” but not assessments.

Let us be clear: we are parents, not educators. We do not pretend to know this is the right solution for Florida. Our goal here is to start the conversation. We hope that discussion will include educators and not just legislators. We believe Florida should be investigating ALL educationally sound methods of accountability, discussing pros and cons, and piloting programs that show promise. We would like new programs to be considered based on their merits rather than their alignment with a particular ideology. Performance Based Assessments are just one promising option.

The best studied example of Performance Based Assessments, as discussed by Mr. Mathews, is the New York Performance Standards Consortium. From their website http://performanceassessment.org :

“The New York Performance Standards Consortium represents 28 schools across New York State. Formed in 1997, the Consortium opposes high stakes tests arguing that “one size does not fit all.”

Despite skepticism that an alternative to high stakes tests could work, the New York Performance Standards Consortium has done just that…developed an assessment system that leads to quality teaching, that enhances rather than compromises our students’ education. Consortium school graduates go on to college and are successful.”

The main components of the system are:

  • Practitioner-designed and student-focused assessment tasks
  • External evaluators for written and oral student work
  • Moderation studies to establish reliability
  • Extensive professional development
  • Predictive validity based on graduates’ college success

Report here DataReport_NY_PSC

The success of the program is obvious when the Consortium Schools are compared to NYC Public High Schools:

  • Higher 4  and 5 year Graduation Rates (68.6% and 76.0% vs 59.0% and 66.1%).
  • Fewer Dropouts (5.3% vs 11.8%).
  • Higher Graduation rates for Black and Hispanic Students (60.8% vs 53.9% and 64.9% vs 51.8%, respectively).
  • Dramatically higher Graduation Rates for English Language Learners (69.5% vs 39.7%).
  • Dramatically higher Graduation Rates for Special Needs Students (50.0% vs 24.7%).
  • Impressive Minority Male College Acceptance rates 2011: 86% AA male consortium graduates accepted to college 2011 (37% national), 90% Latino Male Consortium student (42% nationally).
  • Lower teacher turnover than other groups of NYC public schools.
  • Lower Suspension rates than other NYC school.

Consortium Schools have essentially identical demographics, with regard to ethnicity, special needs and poverty levels  in the schools. Students come to the consortium at a slightly lower proficiency level: 2.71 vs 2.76 for NYC (out of 4.5).

These public schools in New York have created an alternative to the “status quo” and have achieved great success, especially for the most at-risk students, without reliance on high stakes standardized tests.

New York City is not alone…

New Hampshire educators took interest in the success of performance assessments and have launched a state led program to maintain accountability and reduce the amount standardized testing in New Hampshire public schools via Performance Assessment of Competency Education. Read about the program here.

PACE is a first-in-the-nation accountability strategy that offers a reduced level of standardized testing together with locally developed common performance assessments. These assessments are designed to support deeper learning through competency education, and to be more integrated into students’ day-to-day work than current standardized tests. Meaningful assessment is a key part of a strategy to ensure students are getting the most out of their education.

With PACE, New Hampshire does not eliminate the use of standardized testing but reduces state mandated testing, in participating schools, from annually to once each in elementary, middle and high school.

New Hampshire’s PACE program was piloted in two high schools, beginning in 2009, and since implementation both schools reported significant drops in course failures and dropout rates. Read about the success here.

We applaud New Hampshire’s thoughtful investigation of Performance Based Assessments. We believe Performance Based Assessments might be a potential “cure” for #accountabaloney. What other successful programs are out there? Is Florida willing to fully investigate them? As parents, we ask only that our Legislature and Department of Education, rather than stubbornly insisting on the current system, consider options to test based accountability.

 

 

Similar Posts

149 Comments

  17. The entire Neosurf Casino Australia download process is secure, encrypted, and verified to protect your device and personal information. You’ll need to enable “Install from Unknown Sources” in your device settings before proceeding with the casino https://parables.blog/forum/topic/aussie-neosurf-casinos-deposits-payouts-key-risks/ app installation. The casino Neosurf app also functions perfectly on tablets, providing a larger screen experience ideal for live dealer games and detailed slot graphics. Australian players benefit from instant access to exclusive mobile bonuses, push notifications for promotions, and the ability to deposit using Neosurf vouchers directly through the app. The Neosurf Casino mobile app is packed with features that enhance your gaming experience and make every session more enjoyable.

  18. Yes, there are a few caveats regarding withdrawals, but this is the lesser of two evils given the complexity of the gaming landscape for Aussie punters. In second place are Visa and MasterCard casinos; they have the edge over vouchers in terms of versatility, and many players are simply more accustomed to using them. There is another drawback to Australian online casinos accepting Neosurf that high rollers should bear in mind. Casino Neosurf only accepts deposits; to withdraw funds, you’ll need to find an alternative. Thousands of online pokies Neosurf, hundreds of live tables, dozens of crash games and arcade games – all of these become eligible for real-money betting as soon as you redeem your voucher. This payment method makes it possible to play absolutely every type of game available at gambling clubs.

    References: https://community.openedr.com/t/casino-neosurf-australia-deposits-fees-safety/2206

  19. Die Einzahlung im https://weberberg.de/index.php/gaestebuch/topic/casino-mit-deutscher-lizenz-trustly-sicher-einzahlen/ Casino wird in der Regel immer nach einem identischen Schema durchgeführt. Die Wartezeit bis zur Gutschrift deiner Gewinne kannst du dir so locker verkürzen. Am besten suchst du dir einen Anbieter, der eine sofortige Bearbeitung der Auszahlungsanfragen verspricht. Dennoch ist es natürlich ratsam, den Anbieter auf mögliche Zahlungsgebühren zu prüfen.

  20. Ein gutes Casino mit Trustly spart Umwege bei der Zahlung und macht Ein- und Auszahlungen deutlich angenehmer. Dadurch kannst du schon mit dem Spielen beginnen, bevor deine Zahlung auf dem Bankkonto des Online Casinos eingeht. Bei den Top Online Spielos wie Betano erfolgt die Auszahlung mit der Zahlungsmethode oft innerhalb von nur einem Tag. Wenn du schnelle und sichere Ein- und Auszahlungen direkt über dein Online-Banking vornehmen möchtest, ist https://bkonline.id/ruang-cerita/topic/trustly-casino-top-10-sicher-vergleichen-in-deutschland/ für dich geeignet. Je nach Anbieter wird der Betrag deinem Bankkonto innerhalb von 1 bis 2 Tagen gutgeschrieben. Im Kassenbereich wählst du hierfür die Auszahlung aus und klickst auf Trustly.

  22. Die Bonusbedingungen sind ein entscheidender Faktor, der vor der Annahme eines Willkommensbonus gründlich geprüft werden sollte. Um sicherzugehen, empfiehlt es sich dennoch, die spezifischen Bonusbedingungen sorgfältig durchzulesen, da ein besonderer https://stillburning.live/forum/public/d/40-casino-slots-mit-sofort-einzahlen-auszahlen-prufen selten angeboten wird. Sollten Nutzer an einen Glücksspielanbieter geraten, der hier nicht zu finden ist aber dennoch Klarna als Zahlungsmethode anbietet, sollte sichergestellt werden, dass der Anbieter diese Kriterien einhält. Die oben genannten Faktoren sind in allen hier gelisteten Klarna Online Casinos gegeben. Für die Nutzung ist kein eigenständiges Klarna Konto erforderlich – und die Zahlungen sind in wenigen Schritten durchgeführt.

  26. This Pokiesworld page provides comprehensive details about bank transfer casino houses to our readers. Instant wire transfer casino to check with the bank and the casino’s terms and conditions to understand any potential costs involved. When you make a wire transfer deposit, the money is transferred directly from your bank account into the casino account. Thankfully, most payment providers handle this for you, cutting out the groundwork. As long as you’re working with a reputable bank or payment provider, you’re good to go.

    References: https://sikhforum.de/forum/topic/a-clear-guide-to-best-bank-wire-casinos-australia/

  29. Bei dieser werden keine persönlichen Zahlungsinfos mit dem Casino geteilt. Hierzu sollte ein Online Banking Account auf dem Smartphone eingerichtet sein, um Abwicklungen direkt per TAN-Bestätigung freigeben zu können. Wer bequem und schnell unterwegs mit Echtgeld am Online Casino Geschehen teilnehmen möchte, muss nur wenige Dinge beachten.

    References: https://primevil.co.uk/forum/topic/68/

  34. Das liegt in diesem Fall daran, dass eure Bank nicht mit dem schwedischen Finanzdienstleister zusammenarbeitet. Der Zahlungsverkehr mit Trustly bietet Ihnen sogar einige entscheidende Vorteile gegenüber anderen Anbietern. Wie Sie sehen, ist das Bezahlen mit Trustly ganz einfach. Wie sehen also diese Vorteile im Detail aus, die Ihnen https://thebigfootclub.com/forum/topic/bestes-trustly-casino-sicher-wahlen-schnell-zahlen/ für das Glücksspiel in Ihrem Online Casino verspricht? So stellen wir sicher, dass das jeweilige Online Casino Trustly auch hält, was es verspricht, idealerweise natürlich auf Deutsch!

  38. Here’s a list of Mastercard-friendly casinos for you to check out. And while some Aussie PayID casinos put daily or per-transaction limits in place, they’re usually honest about it, so you won’t get caught off guard. Now, if you want more info or a side-by-side look at which casinos pay out fastest, check out this page and learn all about it. Most decent PayID online casinos still get your withdrawal sorted within 24 hours, which easily beats cards or e wallets. Now, to sum it all up, PayID is the fastest, safest, and most convenient way to make real money deposits at Aussie casinos. If you want more details about banking with PayID, check out this guide.

    References: https://the-writer.com/d/516-australian-payid-pokies-instant-deposits-for-aussie-online-slots

  41. Keine Registrierung, sichere Einzahlung, erklassige Bonusangebote, deutscher Kundenservice und Gewinnauszahlung innerhalb von 15 Minuten sind nur einige der Vorteile von SchnellWetten. SchnellWetten ist ein Anbieter von Sportwetten in Deutschland und arbeitet ebenfalls mit Trustly und Pay N Play zusammen. Das liegt nicht zuletzt daran, dass Deutschland im internationalen Vergleich technologisch hinterher hinkt. Zunächst hört sich ein https://forum.datatableswebutility.net/public/d/3-trustly-auszahlung-erfahrungen-dauer-kosten-probleme ohne Registrierung illusorisch und vielleicht sogar unseriös an, doch genau der Gegenteil ist der Fall!

  42. Here’s a breakdown of the most common bonus types you’ll come across and why they’re worth looking out for. If you’re depositing with a Neosurf voucher, you’re not just choosing privacy and control, you’re also unlocking access to some of the most generous casino bonuses on the market. Look for the Neosurf logo in the cashier section, check whether the site offers bonuses for Neosurf deposits, and confirm that the casino supports Australian players.

    References: https://www.tellyflix.com/iptv-forum/topic/neosurf-baccarat-australia-payments-rules-risks/

  48. Schnelle und sichere Einzahlungen innerhalb von Sekunden ohne vorherige Registrierung – dies ist der entscheidende Vorteil von https://www.minehop.net/d/708-trustly-casino-ohne-geb%C3%BChren-kosten-sicher-pr%C3%BCfen. Wir denken hier an die Trustly Pay n Play Casinos, also die Trustly Casinos ohne Anmeldung. Dies bedeutet, dass du die Zahlungen aus deinem Online-Banking heraus ausführst, keine Trustly Registrierung benötigst und trotzdem sofort spielen kannst.

  55. Dazu gehört in erster Linie die Sicherheit und Seriosität, aber auch die Spieleauswahl, ein gelungenes Bonusprogramm und eine mobile App. Natürlich findet ihr in meinem Ranking nur sichere und seriöse Online Spielbanken mit einem guten Gesamtpaket ihren Platz. Bis dahin findet ihr im nachfolgendem FAQ-Bereich die Antworten auf die häufigsten Fragen zu den Online Anbietern mit dieser Zahlungsmethode. Wer dagegen gerne mit Bargeld einzahlt, kann auch die beliebte paysafecard nutzen oder mit CashToCode an einer der zahlreichen Vertriebsstellen bezahlen. Dazu kommt die Möglichkeit, eure Lieblingstitel per Mobile App zu nutzen, wann immer ihr wollt.

    References: https://osi-club.org/praktikaboerse/topic/beste-trustly-casinos-sicher-einzahlen-und-auszahlen/

  58. It keeps spending fixed, avoids card details, and works well for smaller deposits. All three offer $10-$20 minimum deposits, instant Neosurf processing, strong security, and excellent reputations within the Australian gambling community. Account creation takes under two minutes and is entirely optional. Simply purchase a voucher, receive your 10-digit PIN code, and use it directly at the casino cashier. The instant nature of https://forum.sfnl.scot/d/447-neosurf-casinos-australia-2026-instant-deposits-no-bank-needed deposits is one of its primary advantages over bank transfers (2-5 days) and some card deposits (15-30 minutes). This makes Neosurf significantly safer than credit cards or direct bank transfers for online gambling purposes.

  60. You will need to sign up for a player account by supplying all requested details, such as your full name, address, gender and date of birth. In the same right, there is also a plethora of different withdrawal methods available for all to make use of when playing at online casinos. When it comes to withdrawal processing times, you need to consider that different casinos have different processing speeds.

    References: https://engagefortheplanet.comparative.space/forum/topic/need-a-recommendation-on-legit-wire-transfer-casinos-australia/

  61. NPP cashouts avoid this complication entirely; AUD lands in your bank account at face value. This applies to pokies, table games, sports betting, and lottery wins for ordinary players — including winnings transferred via NPP to your AU bank account. The best PayID online casino sites typically support both rails so players can choose. Most operators charge 2%–3% on card deposits and prefer you use the instant transfer option. Slow deposits and slow cashouts turn even the best game library into a frustrating experience.

    References: https://paper-auk.pikapod.net/d/37-australian-online-pokies-payid-instant-deposits-and-fast-pokies-play-for-aussies

  62. https://forum.riskofficer.tech/t/brand-new-neosurf-casinos-australia-essential-guide/34 cards are single-direction instruments — they carry value from a retail point to a recipient, but there’s no mechanism for value to flow back. When you win and want to collect your proceeds, you’ll use a different method. There is no cashout back to the card — the system doesn’t support it by design. A rejected entry never deducts from the card value — you cannot accidentally spend a balance through a failed transaction.

  100. Using PayID as your payment method at online casinos in Australia not only offers quick and secure transactions but also opens the door to a variety of exciting bonuses. When it comes to withdrawals in online https://modernmissouripioneers.com/community/topic/how-to-restore-payid-pokies-no-deposit-bonus/, the usual limits range from AU$ 50 to AU$ 10,000 per transaction. The Pay ID transfer itself is close to instant after approval — the main variable is how long the payid withdrawal casino spends checking KYC, wagering completion, and risk flags before it initiates the payment. At payid online casinos, you use the casino’s Pay ID address for deposits and your own Pay ID for withdrawals, with transfers routed securely through your bank’s own app environment. If a brand routinely leaves Pay ID withdrawals in pending status for more than two business days without explanation, it should not be treated as a genuine instant payid withdrawal casino regardless of what its marketing claims about casinos with PayID. The first window is casino approval time — how long the operator spends running its own KYC, wagering, and fraud checks before it releases the funds.

  102. After a close review, we’ve put together a list of the top sites using this quick and simple payment option. In this section, we will discuss the features found at Australian online casinos that accept Neosurf payment options. We should consider fees, speed, and security when selecting a payment option. The list below covers operators that actively accept Neosurf for AU players, with the details that actually affect your bankroll. The standard welcome package of up to A$5,000 and 400 free spins is great, but my personal favourite here is the VIP first deposit bonus, which includes a 150% match, a VIP trial, and 10% cashback.

    References: https://litesync.io/forum/d/135-how-neosurf-works-at-online-casinos-australian-guide

  103. Once you have a prepaid card in your hands, you’re all set in terms of payment. Making a deposit with Neosurf is pretty simple and it doesn’t require you to have a credit card. It’s sure not as widespread as credit card payments, but you can find plenty of https://www.argcsoficial.com.ar/community/topic/how-to-spot-dodgy-neosurf-10-deposit-casinos/ out there. Commissions that we receive for marketing brands do not affect the gaming experience of a User.

  106. Browse through the list of casinos displayed above, and choose the best online casino with PayID. Once you have created your PayID account, you can proceed to sign up for an account at your chosen best PayID casino. Likewise, check that the PayID casino in Australia is secure and available from your region. Usually, these sites let you https://www.openbookalchemy.com/forum/topic/how-to-learn-payid-pokies-instant-withdrawal/ deposit, as most sign up bonuses require a deposit to unlock the match deposit or free spins. Most PayID casino sites with bonuses usually offer sign up bonuses (also known as welcome offers). A welcome bonus is one of the most attractive promotions you can claim at a PayID online casino.

  118. These rules ensure that online casinos that accept Neosurf provide safe payments and fair conditions at all times. This ensures every session in casinos that accept Neosurf is based on chance, not manipulation. This makes it easier to start playing immediately on Neosurf online casinos in Australia. In this section, we will discuss the features found at Australian online casinos that accept Neosurf payment options. Choose Neosurf as your payment option, enter your voucher code, and make the qualifying deposit to claim your bonus! Claiming a Neosurf casino bonus is quick and easy if you follow these simple steps.

    References: https://pulsechain-forum.de/d/32-new-neosurf-casinos-australia-what-to-check-first

  132. Wir präsentieren Ihnen die verschiedenen Vor- und Nachteile von Trustly kompakt und auf einen Blick. Da https://forum.camping-ausruestung24.de/d/13422-trustly-casinos-zahlungen-sicherheit-und-auswahl direkt mit Ihrem Girokonto verbunden ist, sind Rückbuchungen unter Umständen komplizierter als bei Wallet-Zahlungen. Das Guthaben steht sofort auf dem Spielerkonto bereit, ohne Wartezeit oder Bestätigungsmail. Sie wählen Ihre Bank, authentifizieren sich über Ihr gewohntes Online-Banking-Verfahren und bestätigen den Betrag. Sie brauchen kein zusätzliches Konto, keine App und keine Vorab-Registrierung bei einem Drittanbieter. Wer gezielt Freispiel-Aktionen nutzen möchte, findet bei lapalingo.de regelmäßig interessante Angebote.

  144. We only recommend online casinos that offer fair deposit and withdrawal limits for Aussies, with a focus on Neosurf as a payment method. At GamblingNerd, we rank all Neosurf casinos according to a specific set of criteria to ensure that our recommendations are both trustworthy and valuable. For players who prefer classic casino table games like blackjack, baccarat, and roulette, Ca$hed Casino might be the best option. This Neosurf casino stands out because it imposes no maximum limits on deposits or withdrawals, offering a far more flexible and convenient banking experience. When it comes to the biggest selection of online pokies, Spinsy Casino is the undisputed leader for Aussie players. Most Australian online casinos that accept Neosurf will offer alternatives such as bank transfer, credit card, or cryptocurrency for withdrawals.

    References: https://forum.webcliq.com/d/20-best-neosurf-casinos-australia-top-au-sites-2026

  145. One of those eggs hides a Mini, Major, or Mega jackpot multiplier, so whatever the total payout of the 5 eggs, the last one will further boost the winnings. The volatility is high, and the RTP is listed at 96.21%, but it feels like a solid 96%. This pokie can be quite budget-friendly, with half-currency bets starting at A$0.10 per spin, and a possible maximum in-game multiplier of 5,000x of your bet. Book of Dragon has 3-tiered jackpots, and their size is directly linked to your bet size.

    References: http://dentalresearchfoundation.com/forum/topic/characteristics-of-payid-pokies-instant-withdrawal-australia/

  149. Durch selbsterklärendes Design der Webseite findet sich jeder Spieler intuitiv zurecht. Auch Paysafecard und PayPal sind bei vielen deutschen Anbietern verfügbar. Beachten Sie, dass die Auszahlungsdauer auch bei e-Wallet Optionen wie Skrill und Neteller zwar sofort passiert, Sie damit aber nur digital über Ihren Gewinn verfügen. Neben bekannten Video-Slots finden Spieler auch klassische Automaten mit wenigen Walzen. Bonusangebote sind auch in Trustly https://karmicly.de/d/851-trustly-online-banking-casino-zahlungen-im-ueberblick ständig verfügbar. Finden Sie diesbezüglich keine Information auf der Webseite, können Sie einfach beim Kundenservice nachfragen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *