|

Why the Civics EOC Outrage? Oh, Now We Get It…

ByAccountabaloney

On Thursday, we published a post, wondering why the Florida Coalition of School Board Members (FCSBM), whose motto is “Relentlessly Dedicated to Student Success,” would question district strategies designed to help struggling students succeed on state mandated End of Course exams.

After further investigation, we think we understand why these changes in student progression plans would throw this group of ed reforming, privatizing school board members into a tizzy. Hint: it’s not about student success. This appears to be all about privatization via Schools of Hope corporate charter chains. Legislation passed in 2017 (HB7069) allowed state-approved corporate charter (“Hope”) operators to move into communities with perisistently low scoring public schools. This year, some of those schools, ripe for privatization, improved their school grades enough to disrupt the privatizers’ plans. And “Hope supporters”, like the FCSBM, are not happy…

Promotion from middle to high school, F.S. 1003.4156(1)(a) requires students “successfully complete” a Civics course, and take its corresponding state created End of Course exam.  Traditionally, most middle school students take Civics in 7th grade, but that is not required. Last year, some districts delayed Civics to eighth grade for certain struggling readers, with the hope they would be more successful following an extra year of instruction.

When this year’s test scores were released, the FCSBM saw the drop in Civics participation in those districts, along with the rise in passing rates (directly due to fewer struggling readers taking the assessment) and cried foul. The districts insisted such changes to the student progression plan were allowed. The struggling readers aren’t skipping the Civics EOC, it is merely being delayed a year. Next year’s test scores will reflect the returning cohort’s scores and determine whether the the delay led to increased student success.

The percentage of students who take and pass the Civics End of Course exam is one component of the Middle School Grade calculation, worth more than 10% of the School Grade. The score is based on the percentage of passing scores, not the number of test takers. All students taking Civics are required to take the state mandated EOC.

Early reports about the FCSBM’s concerns included remarks from the districts explaining the new student progression plans’ goals to aide struggling students as well as a statement from the Florida Department of Education confirming that delaying Civics to eighth grade was perfectly acceptable. Current state law mandates students take Civics in middle school but does not assign the specific grade level. You would think that would be the end of the story. You would be wrong (the FCSBM does claim to be relentless, after all).

Later in the day, reports of a letter from lawmakers to Florida Education Commissioner Pam Stewart surfaced, accusing Duval, Manatee and Polk County school districts of “potentially undermining the integrity of our state’s public school accountability system through employing questionable testing practices on the state end-of-course exam in civics.”  Five state representatives, including former FCSBM member, Jason Fischer, along with Senator Baxley, signed the letter which referred to the changes in student progression as dishonest and unethical and accused “certain adults running the system” in these districts of being “more committed to their own interests than the interests of the students they serve.” The lawmakers called for a review of existing state testing policies “to ensure these dishonest and unethical practices do not happen again.” (You can read the entire letter here)

It is important to note that signers of the letter included Rep. Bileca and Rep Fisher, who co-sponsored the initial 2017 Schools of Hope bill, HB5105, which later became HB7069. The remaining legislators signing the letter to Stewart, Reps Sullivan, J. Grant and Rommel, along with Senator Baxley, were all vocal supporters of Schools of Hope and/or voted for HB7069.

First of all, legislators, especially House Education Chair, Michael Bileca, calling for a review of existing state testing policies, and the accountabaloney associated with them, is something we have been calling for since our very first blog. We would also like them to investigate whether mandatory third grade retention isn’t designed to raise 4th grade NAEP scores in much the same manner as these Civics scores. (You can read the letter we wrote to Commissioner Stewart regarding our concerns here).

The real concerns of these legislators and their rogue school board member friends, however, do not appear to be the integrity of the accountability system but rather center around lost opportunities to privatize targeted public schools.

Travis Pillow, who writes for Redefined, a paid blog created to promote the nonprofit which runs Florida’s school voucher programs and otherwise advocates for school choice and ed reform, explained how the delay in Civics participation in specific schools, protected those schools from charter takeover (privatization) via Schools of Hope:

“Then there were schools like Matthew Gilbert Middle School in Duval County.

The school has earned D’s and F’s since 2012. Last year, it earned 333 points in the state’s school grading formula and received a D.  This year, it rose to a C, bolstered by improved performance on state civics tests. Last year, 144 students took the civics test, and 47 percent passed. This year, only 44 students took the civics test, and 95 percent passed. Increased social studies scores netted the school 40 points in its A-F score this year, and it earned a total of 402 — enough for a C. Without the civics improvement, it would have narrowly missed a C and faced takeover under Schools of Hope.”

It appears Schools of Hope corporate charter operators were eagerly awaiting failing school scores so they could sweep in and either open new charters or take over failing schools. Unfortunately, when those schools earned “C” grades, their plans were dashed. Supporters of Schools of Hope, like House Speaker Richard Corcoran, the FCSBM and other privatizers have been quick to speak out about the “travesty” of these improved school grades. These schools were supposed to be “failure factories”, after all.

This brouhaha is not about students… it is about privatizers upset that attempts to improve student scores resulted in higher school grades, eliminating some at-risk schools from the “pool” of takeover options for these corporate charter chains.

Schools on the cusp of a “C” grade are the best targets for takeover because they are easier to show turnaround improvement, than schools earning low Fs for years. This outrage is over the schools these privatizers HOPED would fail.

Did the districts delaying Civics enrollment for struggling readers anticipate this, alone, would lead to improved school grades this year?… probably. Does it mean these students aren’t being served? Not necessarily. The Department of Education has confirmed that such changes in student progression are allowed. Clearly the outrage is more about the loss of privatization opportunities.

What was merely a change in student progression, with the aim to help struggling students, has become a brouhaha … it is not about transparency, or gamesmanship or the “integrity of the A-F grading system.” It is about disappointed privatizers who will have to wait to take over these schools. Shame on them.

We hope the Department of Education will see through this malarkey from those with an agenda and allow what is truly in the best interest of children. No two kids are alike. If a child needs extra time to improve their reading skills so they can have a better understanding of Civics (and be more successful on its assessment), why would anyone be upset about that?

Similar Posts

133 Comments

  2. This change was introduced to ensure compliance with regulations and enhance
    security for players. One of the features that makes Neosurf stand out is its simplicity.
    4️⃣ What are the best Australian online casinos that accept Neosurf?
    Most casinos that accept Neosurf are fully optimized for mobile gaming.

    They have a modern style, trendy games, and
    cool features for your fun. You can start
    playing at Neosurf casinos right from your mobile web browser anytime.

    References: mjenjolici.flarum.cloud

  4. Ein echtes Casino ohne Limit gibt es in Deutschland also nur bei Anbietern ohne deutsche Lizenz
    – also bei Casinos mit EU-Lizenzen aus Malta, Curacao oder Gibraltar.
    Die Casinos selbst setzen eigene Einzahlungslimits, die stark variieren. Sollte ein Casino tatsächlich Gebühren verlangen, würde ich die Finger davon lassen – das ist
    ein Warnsignal für unseriöse Anbieter.

    References: online spielautomaten sofort

  10. Fast, consistent payouts with clear limits and no hidden fees rank more favourably.
    We assess whether Neosurf deposits work smoothly,
    then check the casino’s available withdrawal routes, game selection, and overall reliability.
    We also explain how to withdraw through another payment method and what to check
    before choosing a casinos that accept neosurf casino australia option. You can pay in AUD where supported and set a clear limit by choosing the
    voucher value, but Neosurf is generally for deposits only, so check cash-out options before you play.

  13. A casino with 500 no-name slots and no major providers is a warning sign, not a bargain.
    If you’re comfortable with waiting for withdrawals (considering you’ll likely be stuck
    with bank transfers) and want simple deposits and the clearest
    spending limits out there, Neosurf fits that role perfectly.
    Below, you’ll find my picks for the best neosurf casino Neosurf casinos in Australia,
    along with everything you should know about
    using prepaid vouchers for casino deposits. It’s one of the
    most popular prepaid vouchers, and it’s accepted by
    many Australian online casinos.

  15. It has several outstanding features, with its extensive collection being one of them. We’ve reviewed different gaming sites and picked the most reliable ones with impressive offerings. The voucher-based payment method boasts several features that are beneficial to enthusiasts. Online gambling operators in Australia are constantly looking for ways to provide their customers with seamless payment services. Cashing out your winnings depends on the casino’s policies, as https://meta.discourse.cz/t/neosurf-casino-jackpots-australia-deposits-payouts/56 is primarily a deposit method.

  17. Wir haben übrigens eine neue Seite entwickelt, die sich nur um Boni ohne Einzahlung dreht, also schau regelmäßig vorbei unter nodepositcasino.org und sieh zu, wie es wächst Wenn du schon genau weißt, was du willst und keine wichtigen Hintergrundinformationen mehr brauchst, kannst du auch weiter runterscrollen und direkt zu den Angeboten springen. Dazu bietet Löwen Play eine erstklassige mobile Version, die Spielern Flexibilität und Komfort beim Spielen liefert.

    References: https://forum.nexyn.app/d/22-online-casino-sofort-bankuberweisung-sicher-einzahlen

  18. Neosurf is a prepaid voucher system introduced in France in 2004 that provides a secure and anonymous way to pay for online transactions. Moreover, the pros and cons of using Neosurf will be discussed and Australian casinos that accept this payment method will be named. A prepaid voucher can help you set a fixed deposit amount, but it does not remove the risk of gambling losses.

    References: https://haoma.org/wp/forum/topic/brand-new-neosurf-casinos-australia-essential-guide/

  19. Licensed online gambling in Australia covers wagering, such as sports and racing betting with state or territory licensed providers. Neosurf adds extra protection because your banking details are never shared and you can only spend the value of your voucher. You can also enjoy scratch and instant‑win games at Neosurf casinos, perfect for quick play with modest deposits. You can enjoy these titles in RNG format or in a live dealer casino, with the latter allowing interaction with croupiers and other players. Since you’ll find https://forum.pplpeople.com/public/d/31-new-neosurf-casino-australia-what-to-check-first that cost only a few cents per spin, you can get fantastic mileage out of relatively small deposits. Having a few spins on online pokies is an Australian pastime, and you’ll find thousands of titles at the best Neosurf online casinos.

  33. Zu den wichtigen Voraussetzungen gehört, dass auf dem eigenen Computer ein gutes, aktuelles Antivirus-Programm läuft, am besten auch ein Schutz vor Malware. Darüber hinaus können Spieler ebenfalls einiges dazu beitragen, dass Zahlungen im Casino mit Trustly und auch Wett-Zahlungen mit https://www.hablandodecistitis.es/forum/topic/trustly-casino-bonus-angebote-und-bedingungen-prufen/ sicher ausgeführt werden. Die Trustly Casinos sind außerdem zur Gewährleistung des Datenschutzes verpflichtet und arbeiten mit aktueller Verschlüsselung, dass ist auch bei der Nutzung von Trustly im Online Casino der Fall.

  35. Anschließend nutze ich die verschiedenen Spiele und Boni und tätige am Ende auch Auszahlungen. Ich möchte dir dabei helfen, das beste Online Casino mit Sofortüberweisung (oft als Klarna bezeichnet) zu finden. Innerhalb Europas sollten Banküberweisungen ins Ausland jedoch kein Problem sein, da das SEPA-Verfahren auch Überweisungen in großer Höhe kostenlos ermöglicht. In vielen Casinos erhalten Sie die Kontonummer sowie den Namen des Kontoinhabers und den Verwendungszweck im Bereich „Einzahlen”. Durch die direkte Übertragung von Geldern zwischen dem Bankkonto des Spielers und dem Casino-Konto werden sensible Finanzdaten geschützt. Online Casinos mit Banküberweisung akzeptieren, bieten den Spielern eine sichere und zuverlässige Möglichkeit, ihre Ein- und Auszahlungen vorzunehmen.

    References: https://chat.spectre.app/d/187-online-casino-per-sofort-einzahlung-kosten-sicherheit

  37. The above guide addresses the most crucial areas related to Neosurf casino payments. Still, you must open an account and share your personal details to utilize it, essentially forfeiting the voucher’s benefits discussed throughout this guide. Nevertheless, you must not share the 10-digit Neosurf code with anyone or you risk losing the entire value. Minimum deposits – Neosurf is in line with the minimum payment limits of most online casinos, with a minimum value of A$10 per deposit. That’s more than enough to try the 200+ online pokies and casino-style games featured at Uptown Pokies. Uptown Pokies is the best A$10 Neosurf minimum deposit casino in Australia.

    References: https://community.graffain.com/d/15-neosurf-casino-anonymous-australia-privacy-facts

  38. In recent years we have seen a surge in crypto casinos or casinos that accept Bitcoin and other crypto payments. The exact amount of time it’ll take for your casino to process your request is typically 1-to-2 business days, while the cash https://community.alplab.ai/t/best-australian-online-pokies-2026-top-real-money-pokies-sites/75 may take 2-3 more with a fee ranging between $10-$50, on average. Read our expert guide to cash transfer deposits to learn more about this ever-popular casino deposit method. Embrace the future of online casino banking and enjoy a faster, more secure, and more cost-effective way to play. This process typically involves manual intervention and can take several business days to complete.

  40. Read on to learn more about this revolutionary banking method and discover the best Australian online casinos that accept Neosurf. Affiliate commissions from some listed operators help fund this site, but they never influence our opinion, score, or ranking. The solution is insanely popular across the online gambling industry and is offered across most if not all, online casinos that give Australians access to their sites. There’s no rule in the 2001 Act that includes fines for players who access international online casinos.

    References: https://cupraforum.nl/d/3527-new-neosurf-casino-australia-what-to-check-first

  43. The pokies and live casino line-up covers the standard Australian player favourites, and PayID deposits unlock the full offer without extra conditions. Pay ID support is integrated cleanly into the standard cashier flow, so https://www.openbookalchemy.com/forum/topic/how-to-learn-payid-pokies-instant-withdrawal/ deposits go through without friction and online casino PayID withdrawal requests move through the standard approval process without extra bottlenecks. We only represent the safest and most trusted PayID online casinos with Pokies for Australians. You’ll find detailed reviews based on hands-on research, updated as changes appear on gambling sites. PayID deposits typically complete within seconds based on our extensive testing across Australian casinos. Yes, the best PayID withdrawal casinos in Australia are safe as long as they are SSL-encrypted and licensed by reputable authorities like MGA.

  49. We run through research of the market and monitor which brands offer new PayID pokies and support PayID deposits. The reason for this is simple — PayID offers fast, fee-free, and simple transactions. Before any winnings can be withdrawn, a wagering requirement of x40 times the bonus amount must be fulfilled. All bonuses are subject to a wagering requirement of x45 times the bonus amount before any winnings can be withdrawn. All bonuses come with a wagering requirement of x40 times the bonus amount that must be met before any winnings can be withdrawn.

    References: https://www.mashinky.cz/forum/topic/payid-casinos-2026-fastest-withdrawals-tested-0-2h-payouts/

  83. It’s advisable to check the specific terms of the casino we are using, as they can differ significantly. Thus, we might want to consider transferring to an e-wallet or using bank transfers if these options are available. By exploring these exclusive offerings, we can maximize our gaming experience at https://community.openedr.com/t/australian-neosurf-casinos-top-list-2026-roulette77/2011 casinos across Australia. The bonuses offered at Neosurf casinos significantly enhance the gaming experience. A reliable site will have secure banking features to ensure player safety, particularly when using the Neosurf card.

  84. To activate any of the listed bonuses, the user only needs to fund an account with Neosurf Casinos Australia. Generally, the majority of casinos that accept NeoSurf do not support the use of NeoSurf for withdrawal. Therefore, you can enjoy swift, secure, and simple online gaming transactions when you play at any of the suggested NeoSurf online casinos in Australia. Casinos that accept NeoSurf are a great option for Aussie players as they take the confidentiality and safety of their users as a https://forum.neededapps.com/t/neosurf-casino-instant-deposit-australia-key-facts/564 priority.

  91. The game library at Playfina Casino also impressed us, with over 11,000 titles from a broad range of providers. There is an extensive collection of games from multiple providers, including live dealer titles, which gives the platform a full casino feel rather than just a pokie site. On this page, you’ll find the top online https://blog.granitestateshooting.com/forum/topic/neosurf-20-deposit-casino-australia-essential-checks/ deposits and welcome players from Australia.

  93. Online Spielotheken mit Sofortüberweisung bieten für dich als Spieler sehr gute Möglichkeiten. Sowohl Giropay als auch Trustly sind zwei hervorragende Alternativen zu Trustly. Bei Sofortüberweisung handelt es sich um einen Zahlungsmethode, mit dem innerhalb weniger Sekunden Geld vom Bankkonto auf das Spielerkonto im Online https://forum.ofrynio.org/d/781-legale-online-casinos-sofortuberweisung-sicher-einzahlen eingezahlt werden kann. Ein großer Vorteil von Trustly ist, dass über diesen Zahlungsdienstleister auch Auszahlungen möglich sind. Klarna und die damit verbundene Zahlungsmethode Sofortüberweisung ist mittlerweile in fast allen großen Online Casinos zu finden.

  95. Trustly erhebt keine Gebühr auf Einzahlungen, die Casino-Betreiber übernehmen die Kosten. Die Zahlungsmethode ist neutral, das Casino ist es nicht. Wer alle fünf Punkte abhakt, hat ein legales Angebot. GGL-Lizenzinhaber müssen Hinweise auf Suchtrisiken prominent zeigen und Kontosperrungen auf Wunsch binnen weniger Minuten umsetzen. Kein https://forum.rajatudibaba.com/public/d/760-trustly-casino-schnelle-auszahlung-dauer-tipps wird dich an der Stelle im Stich lassen.

  130. The funds will appear in your casino account within seconds, and you’re ready to start playing your favourite pokies or table games. Get ready to discover why thousands of Australian pokies fans and table game enthusiasts are turning to this simple yet powerful payment voucher for their gaming deposits. This comprehensive review will dissect every facet of using Neosurf for online gambling.

    References: https://ewicare.com/forum/tema/australian-neosurf-casinos-suggestions/

  131. PayID casinos are platforms for Australian players who want to skip credit cards and e-wallets. All in all, the best PayID pokies sites mix fast and secure deposits with solid casino bonuses and smooth gameplay. There are even some offshore casinos now set up just for Aussie players who use PayID. Wondering what really sets good PayID casinos in Australia apart from average casino sites? Play at Australian pokies and casinos that accept PayID for fast, secure payments, instant deposits, quick withdrawals, and smooth real money gaming.

    References: https://superdivorcerules.com/forum/topic/how-i-bought-began-with-payid-pokies-instant-withdrawal/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *