|

ICYMI: Florida Education Policy, Not Common Core, Encourages “Teaching to the Test.”

On Thursday, January 31st, Governor Ron DeSantis created quite a stir in the education advocacy community when he announced an executive order to eliminate Common Core in Florida. The Executive Order (EO-19-32) calls for Commissioner of Education, Richard Corcoran, to comprehensively review Florida’s current standards and provide recommended revisions to the Governor by January 1, 2020. In addition to articulating how Florida will eliminate Common Core, the EO calls for “innovative ways to streamline testing” which is something that DeSantis said would allow the measurement of success but also assure “we’re not just teaching to the test.”

On Monday, 2/4/19, during questions at a press event in Jacksonville (where he announced his proposal for expanded Gardiner ESA funding/vouchers, for children with special needs), DeSantis reiterated “You have to measure, we have to know if people are learning or not, but at the same time… I don’t want schools to be a big standardized testing machine…”

We agree! We don’t want our kids attending test prep factories either. But here’s a NEWS FLASH: Common Core State Standards do not mandate “teaching to the test;” however, many of Florida’s own education policies incentivize it. When everything from teacher employment to promotion to 4th grade are tied to state test scores in Math and Reading, the system will do what it can to improve those scores, in those subjects, almost to the exclusion of everything else.

As we have been writing since Day One, unless Florida detaches the high stakes attached to the state mandated standardized tests, a change of test or standards will not put an end to “teaching to the test.” This is what we wrote in our inaugural blog post in September 2015:

The primary problem with high stakes, standardized tests is the “high stakes”, not that the test is standardized. The right tests, when used appropriately, can be used to inform instruction. Currently, in Florida, these tests are being used for almost everything but informing instruction (retention, graduation, remediation, merit pay, school grade, etc).

Campbell’s Law (a social science adage first written about in 1976) says “The more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision-making, the more subject it will be to corruption pressures and the more apt it will be to distort and corrupt the social processes it is intended to monitor”. Campbell’s Law predicted the distortion and corruption to the education system when stakes (like retention, merit pay, school grades) are attached to standardized test scores. Florida’s parents have witnessed the narrowing of curriculum as schools increasingly focus primarily on tested subjects.  The importance of state testing is emphasized at Back to School Nights. Children are asked to track their own data. Some classes are little more than test prep. These disruptions can be traced back to the high stakes attached to test scores in Florida.

https://accountabaloney.com/index.php/2015/09/11/the-sunshine-solution-solves-the-wrong-problem/

Here is an incomplete list of some of the ways that education policy from Tallahassee currently incentivizes educators to focus on test results:

Teacher Pay and Employment

How teachers are paid and whether they retain employment is dependent on student scores on state assessments. Tying teacher pay and employment to test scores, with the passage of SB736 in 2011, incentivized focusing on test preparation and test scores. Initially, half of the teacher’s annual evaluation was tied to student test scores but in 2015 this was decreased to one third. SB736, also, placed all teachers on an annual contract and districts were forbidden from renewing that contract if a teacher had two consecutive unsatisfactory evaluations or a combination of unsatisfactory and needs improvement evaluations over three years. Student scores needed to increase or an educator could lose their job. SB736 made a teacher’s employment dependent on his/her students’ test scores.

Since 2016, some teachers have qualified for significant bonuses, up to $10,000/year (called Best and Brightest) based, in part, on their test score influenced evaluation.

School Grades

Florida’s school grades are calculated almost entirely based on standardized test scores. High performing schools are given excess funding (A+ funds) which are often distributed as teacher bonuses. Low performing schools face turnaround options that include possible closure.

Middle Schools and High Schools score extra points in the school grade calculation when students pass state mandated End of Course Exams in Math, Civics, Biology and U.S. History. In some schools, the entire focus of these courses is passing the state assessment.

School Grades are said to influence property values, placing tremendous community pressure on districts to keep test scores high.

VAM, Turnaround and School Closure

2011’s SB736 also ushered in the use of VAM (Value Added Model) which is an expensive, proprietary algorithm designed to measure student growth on standardized tests for use in teacher evaluations. In 2017, the use of VAM was made optional for districts. Since then, it is unclear whether ANY districts have opted to NOT use VAM. Regardless, the FLDOE continues to use VAM as the sole measure of teacher effectiveness when evaluating turnaround plans. Schools that have persistently low school grades (almost exclusively schools serving high poverty areas) are required to have “turnaround plans” approved by the state. When such plans come before the State Board of Education (FLBOE), the Board has consistently insisted on the dismissal or reassignment of teachers with low VAM scores.

In 2017, HB7069, through its “Schools of Hope” language, required that any school whose test scores earned them a school grade of 2 consecutive Fs or 3 consecutive Ds, be closed or converted to a privatized option, either utilizing and outside management company or convert to a charter school. Persistently low student test scores can now result the closure or privatization of a community’s public school.

Financial incentives for passing scores on AP/IB/AICE exams.

In some case, teachers and schools receive direct payments for their students’ scores. Both teachers and schools receive bonuses for every student who passes an Advanced Placement, IB, or AICE test. Districts receive 0.16 FTE (or just over 1/6th of a student’s annual per pupil funds) for each passing student from the previous year. For some schools, this total can add up quickly.

Teachers receive $50 bonuses for every student with a passing score. An additional bonus of $500 is awarded to teachers who have at least one passing student in a D and F school. Teacher’s with high passing rates can receive hefty bonuses.

State Approves Digital Test Prep and Mandates regular Progress Monitoring (testing)

The Florida Department of Education (FLDOE) requires and approves the assessments and curriculum that turn classrooms into “big standardized testing machines.”

Florida statute requires regular progress monitoring of students in Reading and Math. The FLDOE provides lists of assessments recommended for such progress monitoring. These are the “tests to see if you’re ready to take the tests” that parents complain about and result in the atmosphere of “always testing.”

FLDOE-approved digital curriculum is also used to prepare students for testing. Many districts use these programs, mandating students (as young as 5) complete weekly digital lessons, collecting data and preparing for state testing. In many districts teachers are required to give up face-to-face teaching time to place their students on these programs. In 2017, the FLDOE approved progress monitoring/data collected/test prep programs, like iReady or iStation, as alternatives to the state assessment for 3rd grade retention decisions.

Impact on Students

Of course, despite all these incentives for higher test scores, for most teachers the largest incentive is their desire to see their students succeed. Teachers know that student retention and promotion decisions, high school GPAs and graduation are all dependent on state test scores. Teachers want their students to be well prepared for success.

The current system of assessments in Florida, when coupled with the high stakes accountability system, requires teachers to teach the content that is expected to be on the state assessment. Rather than being tested on what they have been taught, students are taught what will be tested. The entire accountability system rewards those who are best prepared for the state assessment, so a focus on test prep will continue, regardless of a change in standards or assessments.

If Governor DeSantis wants to dismantle “the big standardized testing machine” (and we hope he does), then he should insist on a serious, state wide, discussion regarding the appropriate use of standardized test data and work to detach the high stakes from student test scores. Without that, a standards change, alone, will simple result in more accountabaloney.


Similar Posts

144 Comments

  1. Transaktionen erfolgen sicher und in Echtzeit über das gewohnte Online-Banking, ohne dass
    ein separates Konto oder zusätzliche Software erforderlich ist.
    Auch Ein- und Auszahlungen mit Beste Trustly Casinos Deutschland im Online Casino
    sind von überall möglich. Zuallererst müssen Besucher
    hier gelisteter Casinos keine extra App mehr herunterladen. Wenn ihr in einem Trustly Casino ohne Anmeldung
    gespielt habt und eine Auszahlung durchführen möchtet, entscheidet ihr euch am
    besten für die Auszahlung mit Trustly. Ein zusätzlicher Artikel führt euch
    zu den besten Casinos ohne Konto Verifizierung.

  2. Einige Pay n Play Casinos vergeben automatisch einen Bonus ohne Einzahlung.
    Die Registrierung erfolgt über BankID, sodass Sie keine lästigen Formulare ausfüllen müssen, wie es bei klassischen Online-Casinos üblich war.
    Die zweite Variante nennt sich Pay n Play, bei der die
    Verifizierung automatisch über die Bank erfolgt.Gemeint
    sind dabei Casinos Online mit Sofortüberweisung
    (Sofort) oder Klarna. Unser Team hat viele sofort casinosüberweisung-Casinos auf sichere und zuverlässige Alternativen für die Auszahlung Abwicklung überprüft.
    Willkommen auf der TOP 3 Casino Bewertungsseite von Sofortüberweisung,
    wo Sie die besten Glücksspielseiten mit ihren Vorteilen gegenüber
    anderen Glücksspiel-Portalen in Deutschland finden. Die Einzahlung erfolgt direkt über Ihr Online-Banking und nutzt die Sicherheitsprotokolle Ihrer
    Bank.

  3. Neosurf vouchers in Australia stay valid for 12 months from the purchase date.
    Compare sites for each method on our EcoPayz casinos in Australia,
    POLi casinos in Australia and MiFinity casinos in Australia pages.
    Neosurf casinos in Australia are online casinos that accept Neosurf prepaid vouchers for instant deposits.
    Since you never share bank or card details with the casino, your financial information is never exposed even if the casino’s systems
    were compromised.

  4. These may include details such as your bank’s routing information or
    a unique transaction reference number you must include with your transfer.

    When you use your bank to add cash to your online
    casino account, the process is clear and designed with user-friendliness in mind.
    Modern bank transfers offer efficiency and convenience, providing a direct
    connection between your bank transfer online pokies real money australia and
    casino account- ideal for safe, everyday transactions.

    Second, your bank’s daily cap matters as much as the operator’s
    — check Commonwealth and Westpac gambling limits in your bank account
    before you deposit.

  5. Australian online casinos provide a variety of banking options that
    are simple and easy to use for players. Following these tips will
    ensure that you are ready to play secure in no time! Make sure you know which currencies are accepted, how you can pay, and whether you
    can use your preferred payment method. Also remember that you may not be able to withdraw your special welcome bonus
    until you’ve fulfilled the casino’s bonus conditions.

    References: forum.webcliq.com

  6. After logging into your account, open the deposit section and check the casino payments
    page. After creating your membership, complete the KYC process immediately.
    First, choose one of the casinos included in the payid pokies list we prepared.
    In this section, we will explain how you can make an instant bank transfer within minutes in 5 easy
    steps. Of course, as the first and most important step, your account on an Australian online pokies payid site
    must be verified. Depositing money into a payID pokies casino account is a
    very simple and fast process for Aussie players.

    References: kindheartsng.org

  7. The best online casino PayID withdrawal times we measured came from Lucky7 and Safe Casino.
    And withdraw to the same bank account you deposited from; most operators insist
    on it for anti-money-laundering reasons and will bounce anything else.
    Upload your ID and a proof of address the day you sign up, rather than waiting for the first withdrawal to trigger the request.

    References: gb.deniztuerkmen.com

  8. Bonus eligibility usually requires a higher minimum (A$20–A$30 to qualify for the welcome match).

    Total deposit-to-credit and withdrawal-to-bank times are typically under 30 minutes
    at well-run gambling sites. To start a deposit, you enter the operator’s PayID identifier in your banking
    app and confirm the transfer; funds credit to your account in seconds.
    It’s legal for Australians to use the NPP payment rail at offshore wagering platforms, but the Interactive Gambling Act 2001 makes it illegal for those operators to offer services to
    Australian residents. The full process from “I’ve never gambled online” to “first cashout in my bank account”
    takes about 30 minutes at the operators in our top ten.

    References: freebahais.org

  9. Crypto cashouts are often faster than the NPP rail at LuckyDreams specifically (sub-15 minutes vs 35). Do not attempt to bypass a self-imposed gambling block using alternative payment methods, as these controls are designed to support safe gaming habits. The table below outlines general features across popular options; exact terms depend on each site’s cashier settings. However, the good news is that big Australian banks typically support PayID fee-free. How We Rate At AusGambler, we take pride in being the most trusted source for online https://greeneralia.net/discussion/topic/listen-to-your-customers-they-will-tell-you-all-about-pokies-net-australia-payid/. The following services offer telephone, online, and registration pathways for eligible Australian users.

  10. Ja, denn mit Trustly kannst du Einzahlungen und Auszahlungen deiner Gewinne im Casino vornehmen, sofern dieses Casino diese Zahlungsmethode anbietet. Zusätzlich ist https://discourse-portal.wearerosie.com/t/online-casino-mit-trustly-bezahlen-so-geht-s-sicher/115 im Besitz einer Lizenz der schwedischen Finanzbehörden, um seine Zahlungsdienstleistungen anbieten zu dürfen. Die Auswahl eines vertrauenswürdigen Trustly Casinos basiert unsererseits auf wichtigen Kriterien wie der Sicherheit, der Spielauswahl, den Bonusangeboten und der Qualität des Kundenservices. In Deutschland ist PayPal jedoch nur in Casinos verfügbar, die durch die dortige Glücksspielbehörde lizenziert wurden. Der absolute Klassiker unter den beliebtesten Zahlungsarten im Online Casino ist bei Spielern aus Deutschland, Österreich und der Schweiz PayPal. Immer mehr Spieler nutzen die Möglichkeit, mit Kryptowährungen in Online Casinos einzuzahlen, um Glücksspiel Transaktionen auf ihrem Bankkonto zu vermeiden.

  11. Ripper Casino has a mix of traditional and modern methods. Stay Casino and Rocketplay Casino both accept Bitcoin and Ethereum. Neospin Casino supports cryptocurrency deposits with no fees. Leon Casino accepts Neosurf and Paysafecard. National Casino offers instant deposits via Visa and Mastercard. Withdrawals can take 3-7 business days.

    References: https://www.mrcp.ac.in/forum/topic/aussie-wire-transfer-casinos-5-mistakes-to-avoid/

  12. Das bedeutet, das Casino bietet einen Bonus ohne Einzahlung aus Freispielen und Geldbetrag. Denn ein solches Angebot ist natürlich sehr verlockend, da kein Geld eingezahlt werden muss, aber die Möglichkeit im Casino Echtgeld zu gewinnen trotzdem besteht. Je nach Anbieter werden die Gewinne vom No Deposit https://ezhow.net/resources/forum/topic/handy-casino-klarna-was-geht-wirklich-in-deutschland/ als Echtgeld gezählt oder das Casino zählt den Betrag zum Bonusguthaben. Der Echtgeld Bonus ohne Einzahlung wird auch als „No Deposit Bonus” bezeichnet. Zögert nicht länger und gewinnt kostenloses Spielguthaben mit Top Echtgeld Boni ohne Einzahlung!

  13. Auch wenn das Spielangebot, das Design und die Boni des Casinos Ihnen gefallen und Sie am liebsten sofort loslegen möchten, sollten Sie sich die Zeit nehmen, sich mit den AGBs des Anbieters vertraut zu machen. Wir finden allerdings, dass das Spielen mit der Chance auf echte Gewinnauszahlungen deutlich spannender ist, und schließlich sind dafür ja auch keine hohen Einzahlungen erforderlich. Unabhängig davon, ob Sie mit oder https://meta.discourse.cz/t/trustly-casino-auszahlung-dauer-kosten-ablauf/54 Registrierung spielen, raten wir dringend dazu, nur Online Casinos zu nutzen, die von einer anerkannten Regulierungsbehörde eine offizielle Lizenz erhalten haben.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *