|

What Causes More Learning Loss than the COVID Pandemic?

ByAccountabaloney

Today, the 2022 NAEP results (including state and district comparisons for 4th and 8th grade Reading and Math) will be released. NAEP, or the National Assessment of Educational Progress is the largest nationally representative, continuing evaluation of the condition of education in the United States.  It is often referred to as “The Nations Report Card.”

Whatever the results, you can expect the Florida Department of Education (FLDOE) and Governor DeSantis will put a political spin on them. Additionally, you can expect Florida to suggest its Covid mandates, requiring all public schools to re-open during the delta surge, prevented the learning losses seen in other states (who kept their school buildings closed longer during the pandemic).

Did I forget to mention that NAEP, itself, cautions against interpreting its results as implying causal relationships? I don’t expect DeSantis or the FLDOE will mention that. Nope, Florida will definitely spin any data to prove that our governor’s education mandates during Covid resulted in better outcomes for Florida’s kids. He probably had a hard time sleeping last night, excitedly hoping that California and New York’s NAEP scores were bad.

[To learn more about the common misuses of NAEP results, read this thread by Andrew Ho. He calls it “misNAEPery”, with number one misuse being “correlation is causation.”]

The COVID pandemic definitely had an impact on student learning. Not surprising, students at high poverty schools suffered the most. Also, no surprise, in-person learning was more effective than remote. 

It is quite possible that DeSantis’ COVID policies may have mitigated some of the “learning loss” resulting from remote learning during the pandemic.

Do you you want to know what has been shown to consistently cause WORSE learning loss than COVID?

Vouchers.

Of course, Florida has no intention of reining them back in.

I was recently introduced to the work of Joshua Cowen by an episode of the edu-podcast “Have You Heard” entitled “Moving the Goalposts.” As always, it is worth a listen.

Cowen is a professor of Education Policy at Michigan State University. He also was the founding director and co-director of the Education Policy Innovation Collaborative (EPIC) from 2016 to 2020, where he studied the effectiveness of voucher programs. In his July 2022 op-ed in the Hechinger Report, entitled “After two decades of studying voucher programs, I’m now firmly opposed to them,” he explains why public money should no longer be funding private tuition. The answer: “these programs on balance can severely hinder academic growth — especially for vulnerable kids.” In fact, the losses seen in the Louisiana and Ohio Voucher studies EXCEED the losses seen following Hurricane Katrina and Covid.

Cowen’s Twitter feed (you should follow him, @joshcowenMSU) is full of data, charts and graphs that informed his conclusions – like this one, showing the effect of various policies and events on Student Math Achievement. And you though COVID was bad…

Cowen says he was initially “cautiously optimistic that vouchers could help.” He now says, “In 2022 the evidence is just too stark to justify the use of public money to fund private tuition.”

“There’s also a moral case to be made against voucher programs. They promise low-income families solutions to academic inequality, but what they deliver is often little more than religious indoctrination to go alongside academic outcomes that are worse than before.”

When Cowen compared results of public schools to voucher programs in Milwaukee, post- Katrina Louisiana, Indiana and Ohio, the results were the same: especially for low-income families as well as Black students, vouchers on the whole failed to deliver. And the measurable losses are worse than those seen with the pandemic. Cowen says, “The bottom line is that the research case for vouchers doesn’t hold up to scrutiny, while the research case against them has been flashing warning lights for almost a decade.”

Cowen warns, “Advocates are re-packaging vouchers as a solution to pandemic-related learning loss, while all but insisting that low-income parents ignore the learning loss caused by vouchers themselves.”

So… later today, when you hear DeSantis and the FLDOE blame disappointing NAEP scores on the COVID policies of “lockdown states,” remember that, throughout the pandemic, Florida has continued to expand its voucher programs and DeSantis has promised more of the same during the next legislative session.

If the governor is serious about limiting learning loss, and not merely politicizing it as a campaign strategy, then he should take a serious look at reducing the learning loss associated with voucher participation.

Florida spends more than $2 BILLION annually on publicly funded private school vouchers ($1.3 billion on the Family Empowerment Scholarship, straight out of our local schools’ funding formula, the FEFP, and ~$1 Billion in tax credits for the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship). 63% of those students return to public schools after just 2 years. Gov. DeSantis could use his new FAST progress monitoring data to inform parents of the learning loss that may be happening when they enroll their children in these schools, which currently are not held accountable to any academic standard.

Or… perhaps he is less concerned about learning loss and more interested in advancing his privatization agenda and scoring political points against his partisan foes…

Similar Posts

101 Comments

  2. Pingback: DeSantis Embraces “Adjusting For Demographics” – accountabaloney
  3. Pingback: Looking Ahead to 2023 – The Danger of Universal ESAs – accountabaloney

  15. Registration, when required, is straightforward and can usually be completed in just a couple of minutes with a stable internet connection. All Australian online
    pokies Neosurf on these platforms are available in instant play
    mode, requiring no download and, in some cases, no registration. Neosurf Australian online
    casinos feature enhanced security measures and often provide additional bonuses with each qualifying deposit.

    They stand out among Australian online casinos accepting
    Neosurf for attractive themes with high-definition graphics, and generous potential
    maximum payouts. They are separate awards for new customers with regular/loyal players, offering
    higher value with fair terms and conditions. It does not
    require verification, offering anonymity for players of online casinos
    real money no deposit.

    References: http://www.devopsschool.com

  16. Wer in Deutschland legal Online-Slots anbieten will, braucht eine Erlaubnis der GGL. Diese liegen je Transaktion häufig zwischen 0,5 und 2 Prozent des Betrags, bei Glücksspieltransaktionen teilweise höher. Avi und sein Team testen professionell Online Casino Anbieter und teilen ihre persönlichen Erfahrungen. Aus dem Interesse an Casino Spielen und Poker entstand ein Startup, das heute ein erfolgreiches Unternehmen im Glücksspiel-Bereich ist. Im https://mrsurepunters.ng/forum/topic/trustly-casinos-im-vergleich-sicher-und-schnell-zahlen/ müssen die Spieler für die Zahlung mit Instant Banking keine Gebühr bezahlen. Für das Instant Banking können die Banken eine Gebühr erheben, die sich je nach Bank unterscheidet.

  17. Instead of constantly buying vouchers, which can be inconvenient, you can register within https://forum.roguepenguingames.com/public/d/86-neosurf-casinos-australia-2026-top-casinos-that-accept-neosurf on the official website and get a NeoCash MasterCard. Note that you don’t have to provide any information to register and use the voucher to make a deposit at the online casino. At such sites you will find game features from the world’s top software providers with bonus rounds and free spins. With a Neosurf card, your privacy is protected, so you can join Neosurf voucher casinos in Australia and enjoy a totally secure experience.

  18. Crypto runs 24/7, but fiat withdrawals can move faster during
    business hours when finance teams are on deck. If you spot it listed as an active method
    anywhere, that info is out of date. Skrill and Neteller used to sit neatly between crypto speed and bank convenience.
    Not every internationally licensed casino with bank transfer withdrawal offers PayID
    for withdrawals yet, and some only use it for deposits, so check
    payout availability before you sign up. Beyond speed,
    crypto keeps your winnings off your bank statement, and many crypto casinos don’t
    require full KYC for crypto-only players. Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin skip the banking system, with most withdrawals
    done in 5 to 30 minutes.

  33. Getting started with Pay ID at one of the aussie PayID casinos in this guide is a straightforward process that takes most players under ten minutes from enabling Pay ID in their banking app to making a first deposit. Pay ID works as a first‑class deposit method at every casino in this list, which means you can unlock the main welcome offer with a Pay ID deposit and still complete your online casino PayID withdrawal once wagering requirements are met. Debit cards are familiar and will remain many Australian players’ first instinct when they encounter payid online casinos for the first time, but they are not the ideal tool for modern online casino PayID withdrawal or deposit activity. For players comparing payid withdrawal casino options or looking for two‑way, fast banking at aussie PayID casinos, Pay ID is materially better than vouchers in almost every respect. Neosurf vouchers still show up at some Australian‑facing casinos, particularly in older guides targeting payid pokies Australia searches, but they have clear limitations that make them a poor comparison point for serious payid online casinos evaluation. For payid pokies real money sessions and routine cashouts, Pay ID’s simplicity wins on almost every dimension except maximum ceiling.

    References: https://thebigfootclub.com/forum/topic/best-online-pokies-in-australia-top-real-money-sites/

  48. Standard bank wire transfers suit Australian players withdrawing large sums. Bank transfers, including PayID and OSKO, suit Australian players moving larger amounts. They provide great convenience for regular players, though some pokie sites exclude e-wallet deposits from welcome bonus offers. Digital wallets like Skrill and Neteller offer instant deposits and fast withdrawals, usually clearing within 24 hours. Aimed at retaining existing players, these promotions are usually available on recurring schedules, such as a set day each week. Those terms determine how an offer applies to your play and whether winnings from bonus rounds can be withdrawn.

    References: https://www.sql-europe.com/forums/topic/highest-paying-bpay-pokies-overview/

  64. For more insights on live casino gaming, payment options, and other Australia-focused gambling guides, explore our expert reviews. All of the https://www.tellyflix.com/iptv-forum/topic/top-10-mistakes-on-payid-online-casino-that-you-can-easlily-right-today/ Australia sites featured in this review can be accessed through iOS and Android devices. When you join any of our recommended live casinos with PayID deposit options, you’ll be entitled to claim a range of exciting bonuses.

  66. Hier unten habe ich die neuesten Online Casinos mit Klarna für euch bereitgestellt und überprüft, welche Besonderheit sie euch zu bieten haben. Ebenfalls solltet ihr im Hinterkopf behalten, dass es sich bei diesen Offerten nicht um einen Bonus ohne Einzahlung bzw. Zwar sind die Gratisdrehs kostenlos, dennoch müsst ihr euch auch bei diesen Angeboten die Bedingungen für Online https://forum.ofrynio.org/d/781-legale-online-casinos-sofortuberweisung-sicher-einzahlen Freispiele genau anschauen.

  86. Cryptocurrencies offered in Bitcoin casinos, Litecoin casinos, and Ripple casinos have gained popularity as alternative payment methods in online casinos. They are trusted and reliable methods that provide ease of use and widespread acceptance. Then you’ll have to scratch off the code and use it to pay at your favourite online casino. Below you’ll find the top alternatives to the aforementioned payment service. Join a trusted PayID pokies Australia site and enjoy gaming that’s as fast as your next spin. The best online pokies Australia PayID and Australian pokies PayID platforms ensure speed, simplicity, and reliability every step of the way.

    References: https://godcurse.com/forum/topic/you-will-thank-us-nine-tips-about-online-pokies-payid-deposit-you-need-to-know/

  88. Similarly to Paysafe, Neosurf offers vouchers that can be bought from your local shop or online. Neosurf does not require input of personal details and is accepted at all licensed online casinos that operate in Australia. The reason we cannot recommend this Aussie casino enough is its unique branding, long list of jackpot games, and 3D pokies with special features. Additional promo codes at Fair Go ensure your balance remains in the black. Uptown Pokies is the best A$10 https://forum.neededapps.com/t/neosurf-casino-welcome-bonus-australia-terms-tips/565 in Australia.

  89. Im Gegensatz zu einigen digitalen Zahlungsmethoden können Spieler mit Trustly sowohl Geld einzahlen als auch Gewinne aus Online Casinos auszahlen lassen. Neue https://jp-shingaku.com/forum/topic/trustly-instant-banking-casino-sicher-ein-auszahlen/ setzen auf moderne Sicherheitsfunktionen und Verschlüsselungstechnologien, um die Bankdaten der Spieler zu schützen. Die Trustly Zahlungsmethode ist einfach zu bedienen und verfügt über eine praktische mobile App, mit der Sie Ihr Lieblings-Casinospiel auch unterwegs spielen können. Obwohl Trustly weiterhin ein weltweit akzeptiertes Zahlungsportal in Online Casinos ist, können Spieler auch andere Zahlungsmethoden nutzen, um Geld einzuzahlen oder abzuheben. Beachten Sie, dass die meisten Bonusangebote eine Mindesteinzahlung erfordern und die Bonusgelder nach einer bestimmten Zeit verfallen. In diesem Abschnitt bieten wir einen umfassenden Vergleich zwischen Trustly und Paysafecard Casinos und beleuchten die jeweiligen Vor- und Nachteile aus allen Blickwinkeln.

  98. Regular updates ensure you have access to all the newest titles, making your gaming experience better every time around. Additionally, withdrawal times may vary depending on the casino’s processing policies and bank procedures. You can still make deposit payments with PayID; simply choose a different method for making your withdrawals, and you’ll be able to cash out any winnings you accumulate. You may even receive free spins for using specific deposit methods (like PayID), so be sure to check your email regularly so you don’t miss out on any promotions that hit your inbox. So, if your chosen casino offers thousands of slot titles, you’ll have thousands of PayID pokies to choose from!

    References: https://paper-auk.pikapod.net/d/36-australian-payid-pokies-the-complete-guide-for-aussie-players

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *